Chronicles of Love & Resentment

Essay series by Eric Gans · Since 1995 · 879 entries

Antisemitism and Jewish Firstness: On Dara Horn’s The Final Solution to the Jewish Question

No. 879
ISSN 3066-6848Open Access gratis

Print

Dara Horn’s The Final Solution to the Jewish Question: A Love Story for the Living (Simon & Schuster, 2026)

Dara Horn’s recent New York Times best-seller, with its supremely ironic title, opens up an obvious yet rarely taken path to Jewish studies: the effort to reveal to the non-Jewish public the real essence of Judaism, and in so doing demonstrate why the world has not been able to avoid reacting—so often strongly and negatively—to this tiny fragment of the human population that first conceived the monotheism that is the basis of the Abrahamic religions and of Western civilization.

Most of the book recounts Horn’s activities in teaching about the reality of Judaism in many fora around the country, taking a leading role in dispelling ignorance and whetting curiosity. Clearly she has had considerable influence in promoting the teaching not merely of Jewish religion but of Jewish civilization and its seminal contribution to Western and world civilization.

Horn tells the story of her discovery, after years of writing and teaching within and about Jewish culture, that the “final solution” to the problem posed by the general ignorance that surrounds it is to recognize that the “prejudice” against the Jews that we call antisemitism has led to a grave misunderstanding of the nature and significance of their historical role—one shared by all too many of the Jews themselves. And that the solution is—dare I say, to take the bull by the horns?—in proudly telling her people’s story.

Thus Horn tells us of her efforts to sponsor learning sessions about Judaism in schools, and her insistence that teaching about Jewish life not be focused obsessively on the Holocaust. Above all, she denounces the myth that the appropriate remedy for antisemitism is that exemplified in the 1947 film Gentleman’s Agreement, which stars Gregory Peck as a non-Jewish journalist who goes undercover as a Jew to observe how he is treated. Indeed, he experiences a great deal of prejudice and comes to the conclusion that antisemites are “persistent little traitors to everything this country stands for… You’ve got to fight them.” But the “fight” consists in implementing the solution to this problem largely adopted by the Jews of that postwar generation: the decision to “become a religion,” that is, to agree to define the Jewish people simply as part of our American “community of Christians and Jews,” while minimizing the features of Jewish culture that are truly original and historically significant—and potentially disturbing to non-Jews.


Yet in order truly to explain the millennial problem of antisemitism, one must explain why it is indeed unique among the world’s prejudices.

This uniqueness is deftly exemplified in the late satirist Tom Lehrer’s (1928–2025) song “National Brotherhood Week,” which, after first listing a number of more specific hatreds:

Oh, the white folks hate the black folks
And the black folks hate the white folks
To hate all but the right folks
Is an old established rule

Oh, the poor folks hate the rich folks
And the rich folks hate the poor folks
All of my folks hate all of your folks
It’s American as apple pie

concludes the sequence with:

Oh the Protestants hate the Catholics
And the Catholics hate the Protestants
And the Hindus hate the Muslims
And everybody hates the Jews

To explain this anomaly, it is necessary to focus on the fact that the antisemite’s hostility to the Jew is not a simple “prejudice” that expresses a sense of superiority, but on the contrary, an expression of resentment of Jewish uniqueness, or more precisely, firstness. Resentment is an unavowed feeling of injustice that explains the particular hatred—and destructive violence—that has always characterized it.

Ironically enough, now that Christianity has largely rejected antisemitism, as marked by Pope John Paul II’s calling the Jews “our elder brothers,” the West has accepted and even encouraged immigration from a Muslim world much of which, far from taking this step, has on the contrary responded to the creation of Israel with the ultimate resentful reaction, declaring to the Jews: “you love life, but we love death.” In other words, Islamic faith is so powerful that its believers are happy to sacrifice their lives in its cause, in contrast to the love of life attributed to lesser religions—a contrast frighteningly exemplified last month in the Muslim co-pilot’s attempted suicidal downing of a FlyDubai airplane full of Jews headed to Israel. Horn would turn this around by her repeated insistence that we “choose life!” But the point of “loving death” is to choose it not simply for oneself but for everyone: to bring about the “last judgment” where God’s justice will finally reign—and where those who “love death” will presumably receive the reward of their transcendental faith.

And unless Horn specifically rejects this resentment in arguing that God, whether we call him Allah or Y*H*W*H, wants us to love life rather than death, her touching expressions of love for Judaism and the Jewish people in the concluding chapters will not erase, but only exacerbate, this sentiment. For the Jews’ role in the world is to seek to wean the lovers of death from their sterile belief—to teach that love of life is the true expression of faith in the creator of the universe, whatever name we give to him.


It is important to be aware of the paradoxical nature of the Jewish position: that of a people, am in Hebrew, confident in the truth of its laws, and who has sought to live by them over several millennia, without seeking actively to convert other peoples to its belief—and whose very disinterest in such conversion strikes its rivals as an ultimate sign of arrogance.

This originary sense of being one people among many is not restricted to the Jews, yet they are unique among peoples so few in number as active participants in world history—the creators of a religion, very much their own, yet that is the source of others that have spread around the world.

This role is by no means a reproach to the “younger brothers” in its family. The difference between Judaism and its siblings is one of temporal descendance, and on the Christian example, Islam too should learn to cease reproaching its elder for stubbornly refusing to “update” itself.

The linearity of time means that precedence cannot be undone, and, given that even Hitler’s “final solution” was unable to end its historical existence, Judaism will always remain the elder brother of the other Abrahamic religions. None of which should prevent Jews from recognizing the historical achievements of the complex societies made possible by both their sibling religions and those of Asia. This is all the more true given that Judaism is by nature incompatible with the ideal of world conversion for the sake of bringing about its final triumph. Judaism has no notion of a final apocalypse; on the contrary, it remains always open to the human future.

For antisemites, it is as though Judaism’s persistence alone prevented the realization of their vision of “the end of history.” Yet to truly affirm humanity is not to await the Last Judgment, but to desire our species’ unending historical progress. Judaism’s lack of any apocalyptic vision for “the end times” only demonstrates its humanism, its faith in humanity—its ultimate lesson to human history.

And indeed, I believe that to make this point—without attacking the religions whose vision of the “end time” may tempt them to “love death” in their desire to accelerate its arrival—is the best way for Judaism to dispel their resentment of their “elder brother.” Take away this desire for a “final solution,” a closed temporality, and the resentment will wither away. This is the future we must work toward: not the closure of humanity but its hopefully unlimited self-realization. And in this light, even if humanity must one day perish, we will have fought against it with all the power of love of which we are capable.

Keywords

antisemitismresentmentfirstnessJudaismAbrahamic religionsapocalypseDara Horn
Cite this Chronicle

Gans, Eric. “Antisemitism and Jewish Firstness: On Dara Horn’s The Final Solution to the Jewish Question.” Chronicles of Love & Resentment, No. 879, October 31, 2026. Anthropoetics. https://anthropoetics.org/chronicles/chronicle879/